A Local’s Guide to the Most Loved Coffee Shops in Indianapolis, IN
Indianapolis’s coffee culture is a testament to its vibrant and diverse neighborhoods, from the historic streets of Fountain Square to the bustling Mass Ave. The city’s coffee shops are more than just places to grab a quick brew; they are community hubs, creative spaces, and a reflection of the city’s welcoming spirit. Whether you’re a student looking for a study spot, a professional seeking a place to meet, or a traveler wanting a taste of local flavor, you’ll find a café that feels uniquely Indianapolis.
Here’s a curated guide to 10 of the most loved coffee shops in Indianapolis, cherished by locals and visitors alike.
Indianapolis Originals & Roasters
1. Tinker Coffee Co.
📍 Multiple locations
A true Indianapolis institution, Tinker Coffee is one of the most celebrated coffee brands in the city. As a wholesale roaster that also operates its own cafes, they are known for their high-quality, ethically sourced beans and a commitment to educating their customers about the craft of coffee.
2. Amberson Coffee
📍 2825 N. Emerson Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46218
Amberson Coffee is a gem in the Indianapolis coffee scene, known for its unique and sustainable practices. The cafe is a tip-free establishment that serves drinks to-go in reusable glass jars and offers a curated selection of local groceries, making it a beloved community spot.
3. Calvin Fletcher’s Coffee Co.
📍 647 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203
Located in Fountain Square, Calvin Fletcher’s is a true neighborhood haunt known for its cozy, communal vibe. It’s not just a coffee shop; it’s a non-profit that uses its proceeds to support local charities, making every cup feel like a gift to the community.
4. Quills Coffee
📍 335 W. 9th St., Indianapolis, IN 46202
Originally a Kentucky-based roaster, Quills has become a key player in the Indy specialty coffee scene. Known for their minimalist yet welcoming spaces and a “really good coffee for everyone” motto, they are celebrated for their knowledgeable baristas and commitment to quality.
Neighborhood Gems
5. Bovaconti Coffee
📍 1042 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203
Located in the heart of Fountain Square, Bovaconti is what coffee shop dreams are made of. Housed in a beautifully restored historic building, its retro, old-world charm and stunning aesthetics make it a popular spot for both photos and a perfectly crafted latte.
6. The Roasterie
📍 906 N. Main St., Indianapolis, IN 46203
The Roasterie is a beloved Kansas City original that has made a name for itself in Indianapolis with its high-quality air-roasted coffee. The café offers a unique and welcoming space for coffee lovers to relax and enjoy a meticulously prepared cup.
7. Monon Coffee Co.
📍 920 E. 64th St., Indianapolis, IN 46220
A fixture in the Broad Ripple neighborhood, Monon Coffee Co. is known for its warm, community-driven atmosphere. It’s a go-to spot for locals looking for a classic coffee shop experience and a wide range of beverages and local snacks.
8. Neidhammer Coffee Co.
📍 2102 E. 10th St., Indianapolis, IN 46201
Housed in a beautifully renovated and restored 1901 building on the Near-Eastside, Neidhammer is more than just a coffee shop. It’s a grand, multi-purpose space with towering ceilings and historic charm, making it a perfect spot for a work session or a special coffee break.
9. Rabble Coffee
📍 2110 E. 10th St., Indianapolis, IN 46201
A true neighborhood hangout, Rabble Coffee is a social hub on the Near Eastside. Known for its laid-back vibe and a menu that includes specialty coffee, fresh juices, and vegan options, it’s a place that prioritizes community and good conversation.
Worth a Visit
10. Commissary Barber & Barista
📍 304 E. New York St., Indianapolis, IN 46204
🌐 commissarybarberandbarista.com
Commissary is a small but mighty shop with a unique dual concept: a barbershop and a coffee bar. This downtown spot is loved for its high-quality coffee and its ability to seamlessly blend two distinct services into one stylish and inviting space.
Indianapolis’s coffee landscape is a vibrant and welcoming one. Whether you’re stopping for a quick visit to Tinker Coffee or settling in for a long afternoon at Calvin Fletcher’s, each café offers a distinct and delicious experience that perfectly captures the heart of the Circle City.
